Ian Monroe wrote:
Proposal:
I propose we change policy on en.Wiktionary user-created words
(so-called "protologisms") to exclude them entirely.
(Hereafter, when I say Wiktionary, I mean the English one).
I would recommend that this be adopted as a blanket policy for all of
wiktionary. The specific means of judging which words are "pretend"
will likely vary by language, of course, but the general principle is
universal.
I would be interested to hear any counter-arguments, but I doubt very
much if there are any. Made up words, original words, are quite
beside the point of a dictionary.
There will be some tough judgment calls about neologisms, and I'm not
sure exactly how these should be decided. A "google test" is no good,
although it can be a clever tool for a first check.
--Jimbo