Jimmy Wales <jwales(a)bomis.com> wrote:There has been no policy change at all. Not
unilateral, not by
consensus. Someone writing "please" on a web page does not establish
policy. It doesn't even _purport falsely_ to establish policy.
If someone had written, out of the blue: "You are required to post a
notice" -- yeah, that would be wrong. But writing "Please post a
notice" does not imply policy, and *note well*, you can edit that page
just as well as anyone else.
--Jimbo
Jimbo, you haven't been following the history properly. All of a sudden, on August
17th, mav wrote this on my Talk page:
"When you list a page on Votes for deletion you must say "Listed on Votes for
deletion" on the page you are listing. Otherwise the page will not get deleted.--mav
00:59, 17 Aug 2003 (UTC) "
Note the emphasis on "must". This was the first I had heard of it. It was
never discussed on the mailing list, it doesn't seem to have had any discussion
anywhere. It just suddenly appeared. And when I questioned it, I was told "It's
policy", and if I didn't toe the line, I could lump it.
This is not "please", this is an order. I was ordered to do as Mav said, based
on what someone without comment had put on the Votes for Deletion and Deletion policy
pages. And I had no input into the process.
RickK
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! DSL - Now only $29.95 per month!