[WikiEN-l] Please stick to the issue

Mon Jan 12 18:27:33 UTC 2004

Robert wrote:

>Yet few people are responding to the above argument.
>Instead, this list is filled with ad homenin remarks, like
>the below one from Stan:
>
>"Not only have you yourself made the ugliest and most
>hateful personal attacks that I've yet seen on Wikipedia,
>you then have the unmitigated gall to pretend that you
>haven't done anything. It doesn't say much for Wikipedia
>governance that you haven't been banned forever for your
>unacceptable actions."
>
>This is sort of Sad. Stan continually hurls ugly personal
>attacks, while I am only asking that we follow our usual
>NPOV editing procedures. This is called projection, and it
>is neither helpful nor reasonable.
>
OK, then answer this yes or no - did you or did you not say
"Fuck you sick Nazi bastards" to everyone on this mailing list,
and do you think this was an acceptable thing for you to do?

Stan