Erik Moeller wrote:
The tricky question for me is what to do with how-tos.
I think they do
have a place in Wikimedia, and a separate project for them might be a
good idea. This could include gaming walkthroughs -- instructional
materials of any kind. But my biggest hope is for documents from the
open source community to be migrated into the wiki context. There are
thousands of FAQs, HOWTOs and man pages which are still maintained by
single individuals. I made a small effort to change this with
OpenFacts, but this was in 2002, when many of the relevant people were
still convinced that the future was in using a strict workflow
approach within a CMS.
Erik
If the WMF board was more inclined to approve new projects (not any old
thing, but at least allow some new projects), I might be more encouraged
to move the How-to guides to a new project. The problem as I see it is
that as a practical matter, starting a new sister project is an
impossible task unless it is a pet project of a board member, or for the
development team. Just look at how the incubator project and
de.wikiversity were started, and that shows a seeming contempt toward
the user community, especially when compared to this attempt to start
en.wikiversity. One was done by "those in power" and the other by
ordinary Wikimedia users through supposed "proper channels". Guess
which one was started without question?
I have noted on several occasions that I feel it would be more honest if
the WMF board would simply state, for the record, that no new Wikimedia
sister project proposals will be accepted in the near or distant future.
Projects like Wikistandards (which has passed the user vote as well,
and supposedly was submitted to the board for approval) don't even have
a prayer of ever getting accepted. From my viewpoint, the only reason
why Wikiversity is even being considered is because the noise from
ordinary Wikimedia users is enough that the board can't ignore the
request, even if the proposal has been languishing for some time. And
that there has been a demonstration project running on Wikibooks for
over two years. Since Wikibooks current policy is to stop such projects
from ever being developed in the future and the current incubator
project is Wikipedia-only, I don't see that any such future project
could ever be started even on a demonstration basis with current
Wikimedia projects.
--
Robert Scott Horning