Transvestitism is very different from being transgendered, and being
transgendered is again (sometimes) different from being transsexual.
Pre-op or non-op transgendered individuals are certainly not in a
better position legally than GLB individuals.
On 11/10/2007, geni <geniice(a)gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/10/2007, Mark Williamson
<node.ue(a)gmail.com> wrote:
The earlier suggestion that a doctor's note
will be required is also upsetting.
I doubt it. The issue there is that self diagnosis may not be
considered valid I don't know of any case law in this area.
For someone who is biologically a man to live
socially as a woman,
they should not need a doctor's note to avoid persecution. Life is
already more difficult for trans people.
Egyptian law treats men and women differently thus legally someone's
gender at a given time is of some significance.
In response to my earlier letter, I noticed
people bandying about the
term GLBT again. Guys, I am not talking about GLBT here really. I am
talking about T.
GLB people may not be able to be who they are, and for many, that is
going to be a no-go.
But it is the T people for whose safety I fear.
In the trans community there is what is known as "passing", that is
someone who is biologically male being able to live as a female
without anyone noticing them, or vice-versa.
If our trans friends can pass, I do not think they will really be
unsafe as long as they are careful, in the same way they would want to
be careful if they were going on a road trip in Alabama.
If, however, they are among those individuals for whom passing is more
of a challenge, I would very much fear for their safety and think that
this is a matter of life and death rather than just "not flaunting
it". If Jimmy Wales wanted to go to the conference dressed in drag
(not that he wants to, but if he did), and go out on the streets
afterwards and live "as a woman", he should be able to feel
comfortable doing that.
Jimmy Wales is not transsexual.
Transvestism is a separate issue and is treated rather differently.
Now, imagine if you could not feel safe
travelling in the gender you
are. For the men out there, imagine you had to wear fake breasts and
women's clothing to avoid being beaten and harassed? For the women,
imagine you had to cut your hair short, duct tape your cleavage, and
perhaps even stuff your pants to avoid the same? In the majority of
Islamic countries, trans people are not safe unless they deny their
true gender identity. This is unacceptable.
The version of Islam prevalent in Egypt views transsexualism as an
illness and will not oppose any treatment proposed by a doctor.
There is a Fatwā to this effect floating around.
All that aside, what upsets me the most about
this issue is the way
our community has been blown off by just about everyone. Jimmy Wales
was kind enough to at least show some concern; others have called us a
"special interest group" asking for unreasonable things or told us not
to "flaunt it". This has been so highly offensive and so greatly
frustrating that I am having difficulty believing it is coming from
Wikimedians, since our organization is so diverse (if you ever looked,
you would see there is a higher portion of GLBTQ people on Wikimedia
than in society at large).
Legally transsexuals are in a better position than GLBs. Transvestites
less so not sure about furries.
--
geni
_______________________________________________
foundation-l mailing list
foundation-l(a)lists.wikimedia.org
Unsubscribe:
http://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l