Oliver Pereira wrote:
On Sun, 22 Jun 2003, cprompt wrote:
>Erik Moeller wrote:
>
>>Unless there are objections, I intend to ban
"Pizza Puzzle", who
is
>>another incarnation of Lir.
>>
>I haven't had much interaction with this account,
so I can't really
>speak for or against them. I will say that
Adam
hasn't told me about
>this account, and other than being
suspiciously
similar to Adam, and
>making lots of edits, what's the harm? If
it is
another incarnation of
>Lir, and they have the same writing style and
habits, why ban them if
>they aren't harassing other users or
defacing
pages? (Or are they?)
I have an objection. Mr. Puzzle has made quite a
few useful edits, and has
hardly annoyed anyone. The long sequences of small
edits can become
annoying, but as far as I'm aware we're
not running
out of disc space, and
I hear rumours that we may be getting an enhanced
"diff" feature in which
non-consecutive page versions can be compared
using
radio buttons, and if
that's the case then I don't think it
would matter
quite as much.
There has to be a way for people to
redeem
themselves. For Lir, leaving
aside the multiple incarnation issue, the multiple
small edit issue, may
be an editing style that annoys some people, but
looked at alone I would
not consider it a banning offence. What are his
other '''recent'''
offences?
Ec
He has had no recent offences within the articles,
AFAIK just on various talk pages about voting.
-LDan
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! DSL - Now only $29.95 per month!