On 2/27/07, John Lee <johnleemk(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Correction: that's the way *AfD* works. You note
that WP exists to serve the
writers, but most (if not all) of those commenting on certain nominations
may have never written on the topic concerned. That's not to say they should
be ignored, because WP works by consensus, but if the people who know most
about a field are writing about something, or saying that something deserves
an article, then generally shouldn't it be included, unless it fails certain
guidelines/policies, e.g. verifiability?
Johnleemk
Problem is that those argueing for deletion are baseing thier
arguments on the article failing [[Wikipedia:Attribution]].
--
geni