Charles Matthews wrote:
Chad Perrin wrote
Apparently, to you, killing someone for being a
Jew is more wrong than
killing someone for speaking out of turn. To me, it's equivalent in
either case, because in both cases it is murder.
There is a policy on this list about personal attacks.
It's not a personal attack. It's a statement of my analysis of your
apparent views on the matter. I didn't say "Apparently, to you, killing
someone for speaking out of turn isn't wrong." What I said was that you
apparently think it's MORE wrong to murder someone for ethnic reasons
than politically oppressive reasons. If that is not the case, you might
want to think about the logical contradiction in your earlier statements.
To claim I'm making a personal attack is to misrepresent my words and my
intentions. I don't think you're doing so intentionally, but that
opinion will change if you continue to do so after I've explained it for
you.
--
Chad