[WikiEN-l] Dealing with crap deletion nominations

Sun Jan 22 18:26:00 UTC 2006

On 1/22/06, David Gerard <fun at thingy.apana.org.au> wrote:
>
>
> Some AFD regulars seem to view AFD/DRV as an independent fiefdom which
> claims dominion over all Wikipedia content, but resists all comment from
> outside (e.g. wikien-l) as interference. *Unfortunately*, it's been
> causing
> real problems for the Foundation of late. Unbelievable rudeness about
> outsiders, stupendously crap nominations to make a point, actively driving
> away outside experts, etc.
>
> Here is a suggestion: good faith is not enough when the good-faith actions
> are stupidly destructive. Incivility on *FD = 24 hour ban from all *FD
> pages and deletion of comment. Sufficiently crap nomination = 1 month ban
> from all *FD pages.
>
> Ideas?
>
>
> - d.

Nothing wrong with the idea perse, but who decides what is crap?

Mgm