[WikiEN-l] Complicity in hoaxing - how to proceed?

Charles Matthews charles.r.matthews at ntlworld.com
Fri Dec 24 09:31:09 UTC 2004


The current listing at VfD of [[Cayley-Newbirth operation matrix]] has
flushed out User:ExplorerCDT, who at the very least knew this was a hoax
page, and posted comments at VfD designed to obfuscate and mislead.

User:ExplorerCDT is apparently otherwise in good standing as a Wikipedian.
How to proceed in such a case?

Context is that there have been a number of attempts to place hoax pages in
mathematics in the English Wikipedia. This example is evidently written with
at least a well-informed graduate student knowledge (as with the recent
vandalism attack by [[User:Slim Jim]], with plausibe disinformative
tweaking).  The page was been around for eight months, since it has the
look-and-feel of a piece of obscure, dull abstract mathematics quite
accurately.

For myself I would like to see User:ExplorerCDT banned, for bad faith
editing.

Charles







More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list