Robert Graham Merkel wrote:
If the only way we can illustrate a topic is by using
such images (or
other media), then I think we should do so. Provided we have a
mechanism by which reusers of our content can avoid downloading them,
it doesn't seem to be a problem. I do, however, recommend we accept
their use only if it is the only way to provide such images for an
article.
I don't like this idea, because it makes the Wikipedia website seem like
the end product we're trying to produce, which in my view it is not.
We're trying to produce a free encyclopedia, and one way it will be
published is on
wikipedia.org. If an image is only allowed to be
published by us, it is not part of the free encyclopedia, but an
addition to the free encyclopedia only available on one specific website.
Using such images will also tend to discourage the creation or location
of actually free images.
-Mark