--- Yann Forget <yann(a)forget-me.net> wrote:
Hi Anthere and others,
Hello Yann,
So to resume, there are two objections against
Indymedia :
- biaised,
- not GNU FDL.
Is that right ?
However, I would not agree to include a news project
within Wikipedia. An
encyclopedia needs some detachment, to stand back
from current events, to be
able to analyse the facts.
I am sure glad to hear you say that...:-)
On nuclear issues, I would be the happiest if there
would be NPOV articles (I
mean scientific, on facts) on this subject. I think
that people opinions in
favor of nuclear power is mostly because of lack of
knowledge about the
subject. Well, that my opinion after 20 years of
study of the question.
And the articles on this in the English wikipedia
are quite good for me.
thanks for improving a bit the field these past 2 days
:-)
The article on Activiste was put on my page by
Francis. I thought that it
would be, with maybe some little changes, a good
definition of French people
Sure. The difference in meaning is very important to
be mentionned. I agree.
But, the fact it was offered to you by Francis doesnot
make it look more like a non-biased encyclopedic
article. Don't you agree ?
I am reflecting on the activism article and the one on
La Hague, where you removed that big bunch of
information.
http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usine_de_retraitement_de_la_Hague
I am sure glad you appear to know on lot on the
nuclear matter. And I agree the text proposed is not
written in a neutral matter. But I think there is not
much wrong about the core of the infos given.
Similarly, I think there is not much wrong about the
core of the infos given on the activism article, but
the way it is written is not neutral and not
appropriate.
So, both situations need to be handled. It is not
because there are activists, but little pro-nuclear on
the french wiki, that one article should be censored
and not the other. So please, consider that, and do
not censor. Let's try to improve rather.
Thank you Yann
__________________________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Platinum - Watch CBS' NCAA March Madness, live on your desktop!
http://platinum.yahoo.com