Hi Anthere and others,
So to resume, there are two objections against Indymedia :
- biaised,
- not GNU FDL.
Is that right ?
However, I would not agree to include a news project within Wikipedia. An
encyclopedia needs some detachment, to stand back from current events, to be
able to analyse the facts.
On nuclear issues, I would be the happiest if there would be NPOV articles (I
mean scientific, on facts) on this subject. I think that people opinions in
favor of nuclear power is mostly because of lack of knowledge about the
subject. Well, that my opinion after 20 years of study of the question.
And the articles on this in the English wikipedia are quite good for me.
The article on Activiste was put on my page by Francis. I thought that it
would be, with maybe some little changes, a good definition of French people
who called themselves activistes. Actually there is a controversy on the
translation of the English "activiste" into French. I think it is usually
translated as "militant", and that the English "militant" is
translated into
"activiste". But some people think that the French "militant" is to
"passive", so they prefer the word "activiste".
Regards,
Yann
Le Lundi 17 Mars 2003 00:43, Anthere a écrit :
This already
exists. It's called Indymedia :
http://www.indymedia.org.
Yann
I sure would not agree that wikipedia current news are
given by indymedia. Though I support indymedia, I
think they sure are to biaised to fit in the wikipedia
frame. And on the fr wiki, that would likely be done
by Yann.
Excuse me here Yann, but though you are really a good
wikipedian and did *great work* on the fr wikipedia, I
hope you admit you have a rather strong biais, as can
be seen in the nuclear-related articles . I sure hope
that (with Francis maybe) you give us some good
*neutral* articles on activism, anarchism and the
such, but I'll tell you plain, articles such as the
Activiste one that you wrote some time ago
(
http://fr.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?title=Activiste&oldid=34251)
are just way out of line. In particular the end of the
article
--
http://www.forget-me.net
Alternatives sur le Net
http://keys.indymedia.org/showkey.py?key=0A34CBDA
gpg --keyserver
keys.indymedia.org --recv-key 0A34CBDA