[WikiEN-l] Expert editors

Fri Sep 22 15:02:25 UTC 2006

On Sep 17, 2006, at 12:15 AM, geni wrote:

>>
>
> A popular vote of of scientists would not be the worst description of
> what goes on. Although of course the actual process is ar more
> complex.
>

I just see a massive amount of wishful thinking and naivete in the  
proposals @ citizendium.org and mailing list... As if expert editors  
do not have POVs to push, or that politics will not enter such a  
system, or that expert editors with Phd's will be any better at text- 
based social interactions and collaborative editing than mere mortals.

-- Jossi