[WikiEN-l] 100, 000 FAs as an achievable goal with a plan (was Contest and quality)

Wed Sep 13 02:10:53 UTC 2006

On 9/13/06, Carl Peterson <carlopeterson at gmail.com> wrote:
> What would be ideal is if we could establish a content-area (i.e.,
> WikiProject) peer review as a prerequisite for the purposes of content (esp.
> for technical articles) then have it go to a "Brilliant Prose Committee" of
> qualified persons (e.g., people with actual degrees or a lot of experience)
> to evaluate the writing style, the readibility, the grammar, etc. But that
> borders on instruction creep and would be strongly opposed as it creates an
> elite class distinction and would knock out all the lovely people who derive
> meaning in life from firing torpedoes at FACs.
>
> Carl

You have suggested a committee. Generaly that isn't a good sign.
-- 
geni