"Laura Scudder" wrote
I'm am very pro-citation when it helps us build a
better encyclopedia,
but I'm anti-"let's footnote everything even though it appears in any
textbook on the subject and is totally uncontroversial, just to
satisfy a process decision".
I think it's a horrid idea to have any policy on this which would allow people to spam
us with inline references, for example, to their version of The Great American Calculus
Text.
Those books _all_ follow the pattern set down by Thomas of MIT in the 1950s. They are
alike as two peas in a pod. They are written for money, and contain material that has all
been known for 150 years.
Charlee
-----------------------------------------
Email sent from
www.ntlworld.com
Virus-checked using McAfee(R) Software
Visit
www.ntlworld.com/security for more information