On 9/14/05, SPUI <drspui(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Kelly Martin wrote:
Perhaps closing admins should simply ignore
opinions of the form "nn,
delete" and "Keep all schools". People will stop offering such such
bland opinions if they realize that their input is being ignored and
will instead offer more useful commentary.
What if "keep all schools" is the reason the person is voting to keep?
There are many that feel that all X for some X are "notable".
I would recommend that such opinions be given low (or perhaps even no)
weight. Arguments to keep or delete an article on the merits of the
specific article (or, rather, the subject of the article, which should
be the main basis for a keep/delete decision) should be given more
weight than those based on any categories in which the article (or its
subject) might happen to fall in.
Kelly