[WikiEN-l] Re: Article deletion (proposed 1 month hiatus)

Mon Sep 12 22:17:02 UTC 2005

While I agree with much of David Gerard's reasoning, I am unconvinced
that a one-month hiatus would provide any greater or more meaningful
space for discussion of an alternative than would business-as-usual at
AfD.

I do believe that it would lead to a rash of speedy deletions that lack
sufficient policy basis.  

I continue to believe that any discussion of process issues at AfD will
go nowhere until there is greater agreement on what articles we want to
keep and what articles we want to delete.  The process discussions are
all polarized by the winners and losers they would create in the
inclusionism vs. deletionism spectrum.

The Uninvited Co., Inc.