[WikiEN-l] VFU is utterly beyond hope

Sun Oct 16 22:07:17 UTC 2005

On Oct 16, 2005, at 5:21 PM, geni wrote:

> On 10/16/05, Snowspinner <Snowspinner at gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> VfU has never once seen "any" AfD that decides to delete, nor even
>> "most" VfUs that decide to delete get brought up there. This is a
>> complete straw man argument.
>>
>> -Snowspinner
>>
>
> Unless you consider the reason for this may a combination of low
> profile and the knowlage amoungst those that do know about it that
> they would be wasteing there time. Any article that is so important
> that it must be included in wikipedia this year is unlikely to get
> wiped out through AFD.
>

In which case your real argument is that we don't need VFU because  
AfD is flawless - an argument that is not so much a straw man as self- 
evidently absurd.

-Snowspinner