[WikiEN-l] The 3RR is an electric fence, not an entitlement.

Sun Oct 9 06:56:45 UTC 2005

-------------- Original message -------------- 

> On 10/8/05, actionforum at comcast.net wrote: 
> > 
> > Those, who voluntarily 
> > limit themselves to one or two reverts per day, must refrain 
> > from editing certain pages, or return to those pages with 
> > persistance over a long period of time. 
> > 
> 
> That is simply untrue. I've edited George W. Bush, for instance, with my 
> customary 1RR. The Iraq war article, too. I've performed useful edits on 
> those articles, leaving both better than when I found them. Why would this 
> *not* be true? 

I've done that too, however, it does depend on what you
are trying to get in.  I'd be more impressed if you could
get fair representation for anarcho-capitalism on the anarchism
page, or if you could get Castro properly labeled as a dictator.
Or how about getting what everybody expects to be called
communism, the communist state, and criticisms of it on
the communism page. 

Do you ever try the hard stuff on a page with a clique suppressing
other POVs?
                   -- Silverback