[WikiEN-l] Arbitration Commitee Seeking Comment

Sun Jun 5 12:56:51 UTC 2005

steven l. rubenstein (rubenste at ohiou.edu) [050605 22:48]:

> What we need first is a ruling by or concerning the ArbCom that it will 
> consider and pass judgements on content-based disputes, or it will not.  We 
> just need to make this clear, one way or the other.

I can tell you now we have no intention of taking on this one as well! Not
just the amount of work, but simply that that's not what the AC was put
into place for.

> And if ArbCom will not or cannot handle content-based disputes, we need to 
> develop another committee or mechanism.

Well, yeah.

There are all sorts of possible problems. Specialist Point Of View is not
necessarily Neutral Point Of View. That sort of thing.

> I am repeating something I have said several times in the past.  This issue 
> is not new.

That's why it's being discussed here as well :-)

- d.