[WikiEN-l] DNA, Mav, 168

Mon Mar 8 13:41:12 UTC 2004

Anthere wrote

> And I do not think there was an emergency to unsysop
> 24 hours after the reversion war. This should have
> been Jimbo or arbitration committee to decide.

Exactly.  Who decides what is an emergency?  What is an emergency?  Would
something affecting 20 pages, or 0.01% of Wikien, qualify?

Loud talk on this list, unilateral action, lack of a collegial approach - it
all seems to come down to those closest to an active issue reckoning they
are the best judges of its seriousness.

I beg to differ.

Charles