[Commons-l] Editorial use vs commercial exploitation

David Monniaux David.Monniaux at free.fr
Mon Aug 14 19:01:59 UTC 2006


There is a similar issue with the photographs produced by various 
organisations: these organisations would allow commercial use for e.g. 
informations, encyclopedias, education, but not for making advertisements.

In some instances, this is a case of protection of image: they don't 
want their image to be associated with products or political campaigns 
without their authorisation, and it's much easier for them to act on 
grounds of copyright infringement than on other grounds (especially 
since in some cases they cannot claim trademark protection).

This will probably have to be addressed in a satisfactory fashion. 
Currently, we deal with such images by allowing them on some Wikipedias 
(en: in particular) by claiming "fair use". However, many projects don't 
allow "fair use", though their communities would perhaps appreciate 
being able to use such images.



More information about the Commons-l mailing list