On 10/30/2012 08:03 PM, Ori Livneh wrote: Gerrit, for all its problems, does not require the reviewing developer to install extra software and Eclipse is quite a bit of software if the developer isn't already using it. I would suggest that any alternative workflows work on top of and integrate with Gerrit, or if we're all in agreement that we should ditch Gerrit for code review, that the requirements to use them not be so heavyweight as "first, install Eclipse..." That said, if there is a way to use Mylyn without Eclipse, or if there is a way to integrate Mylyn with Gerrit, then I'd be in favor. Gerrit, I think, at least provides us with a central place to keep the reviews. It looks like there is Gerrit integration for Mylyn <http://www.eclipse.org/reviews/gerrit/> so if you like Mylyn it looks like you are free to use it while still working with people who are still using Gerrit. Mark. -- http://hexmode.com/ Any time you have "one overriding idea", and push your idea as a superior ideology, you're going to be wrong. ... The fact is, reality is complicated -- Linus Torvalds <http://hexm.de/mc>