--- Jimmy Wales <jwales(a)bomis.com> wrote:
Daniel Mayer wrote:
Well in order to be "acceptable" in at
least US
public schools,
Wikipedia would have to dramatically censored.
Sadly, state and
local school boards in the US have effectively
censored the content
of textbooks by not accepting material that could
possibly be
offensive to a very long list of lobby groups
(both on the right and
left of the political spectrum).
I wonder if NPOV would be sufficient for the bulk of
this requirement.
What I mean here is that our NPOV policy and wiki
process tends to
make pretty sure that no material is offensive to a
very long list of
wikipedians, from a wide variety of political and
cultural
backgrounds.
Not everything in wikipedia is going to be
considered by mainstream
parents as appropriate for children, that's for
sure. Probably 99%
is, but I acknowledge that a large number of people
do feel that
children should have even NPOV presentations of some
information
withheld from them until they are older.
I heard a news story the other day that in
California, textbooks
are now forbidden to mention Mount Rushmore. See:
http://www.wtvw.com/Global/story.asp?S=1288473
I think that's terrible. Wikipedia, NPOV or not,
should never censor to that degree. We may never be
worthy of becomming a high-school text book, but will
be worthy of much more instead.
Wikipedia would obviously handle that topic
differently. We would not
omit the existence of Mount Rushmore, but we would
cite the names and
arguments of those who find it offensive.
A lot of the excessive political correctness that we
read about in the
news is really just a lack of talent in expression.
It's entirely
possible to talk about controversial things in a way
that is not
itself controversial.
--Jimbo
No, our NPOV stance will always be contravercial. For
some, censorship is absolutely nessesary. For others
(most), inclusion is nessessary. These make it
impossible to have a truely non-contravercial
information source.
--LittleDan
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
The New Yahoo! Search - Faster. Easier. Bingo.
http://search.yahoo.com