RK's
behaviour is no justification
for EoT's response, which breaks just about every
rule of wikiettique
imaginable.
Ettiquette? Hm. I wonder what reception an Arab
Palestinian editor with RK's level of "ettiquette"
might recieve. Oh yes-- you and I reverted some of his
"edits" recently didnt we?
EoT has been repeatedly asked to stop
creating these pages, and
has refused to do so. Jimbo has made it clear that
he HAS to stop, yet he
has continued with the behaviour. In the
circumstances I see no alternative
but to ban EoT. /Any/ user who acted in that manner
in my view forfeits the
right to be on wikipedia.
If this is true then I agree with you. As I understand
it, it is not currently the case. The only edits EofT
seems to be making regarding RK are to the ridiculous
"case" page, which I made to replace and remove those
invasive pages EofT started.
The precedent for /ban pages was already set and was a
bad practice ready to be missapplied -- its important
to clear this up. After Jims "suggestion" that /ban
pages were inappropriate, and EofT's refusal to heed
this "suggestion" -- yes, certainly, EofT is on his
own.
RK's behaviour is grossly unacceptable and needs
to
be confronted also.
Well? Tick, tock, tick, tock... the general
heavyweights may seem to go in favor of banning EofT
-- are they doing it at the request of RK -- a person
whos behaviour is also "grossly unacceptible?"
Wherefore comes this momentum for taking unilateral
action that favors one miscreant over another? What
would Judge Judy do? Throw them both out, I imagine.
EoT, used a *methodology that is
unprecedented in wiki
history and is so far beyond the realm of acceptable
behaviour...
The *methodology you speak of -- /ban pages, and the
creation of excess pages on the matter, although
unusual, did have plenty of precedent, as this was the
method that other "trolls" were "informed" and
"documented" as to their status -- while still active.
Continuing the "Big City Smartass" tradition,
-S-
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software
http://sitebuilder.yahoo.com